If you were a peasant, you could be forgiven if you said that Pope Francis confuses you. Yes, he seems like a nice man. He seems down to earth. But he sends mixed messages. Not long ago, the pope traveled to Cuba. Recently, he visited Mexico. He spoke at a big rally at the border […]
Get Instant Access to This Article
Become a Central New York Business Journal subscriber and get immediate access to all of our subscriber-only content and much more.
- Critical Central New York business news and analysis updated daily.
- Immediate access to all subscriber-only content on our website.
- Get a year's worth of the Print Edition of The Central New York Business Journal.
- Special Feature Publications such as the Book of Lists and Revitalize Greater Binghamton, Mohawk Valley, and Syracuse Magazines
Click here to purchase a paywall bypass link for this article.
If you were a peasant, you could be forgiven if you said that Pope Francis confuses you.
Yes, he seems like a nice man. He seems down to earth. But he sends mixed messages.
Not long ago, the pope traveled to Cuba. Recently, he visited Mexico. He spoke at a big rally at the border with the United States. He spoke of the plight of the immigrants from the south — those who illegally flood across that border. He calls them victims.
Pope Francis calls the Muslim migrants who flood across the borders of Europe victims as well. He calls the refugees from the wars of Africa victims. Well, he is right about that.
Here is what confuses me. Does he praise the U.S. for taking in countless millions of illegals? And millions of legal immigrants, too? No. He criticizes the U.S. for its capitalism.
Does Pope Francis rebuke Mexico for its wall-to-wall corruption? For its drug wars? Some. But mostly, he loves to whack away at the evils of capitalism.
Does the pope rebuke the Castro brothers for imprisoning millions of Cubans for half a century? No. He rewards them with a visit. Does he urge them to free their political prisoners? The prisoners who received no trial? The prisoners who went to jail for simply criticizing the regime? No or not loudly enough.
Does the pope call for free elections for Cubans? So that they could voice their opinions? Does he call for free travel for them?
No, he does not. He seems too busy instead railing against the evils of capitalism.
This is confusing for a few reasons. One is that if Cuba allowed for totally free travel, half the people would be gone in a year. And where would they go? To that evil capitalism in the U.S. They know that Cubans in Miami live 10 times better than Cubans in Cuba. Unless they belong to the communist elite in Cuba.
The pope decries the plight of illegal immigrants from Latin America and Mexico. Who does he blame for their plight? Often he blames America and its evil capitalism.
So where do those immigrants want to go? To America and its evil capitalism.
Does the pope see swarms of immigrants headed for socialist countries? Does he see them try to sneak into Venezuela?
The pope has a lot of reasons to attack communism and extreme socialism. By extreme, I mean enforced — as in Venezuela. Dictators and banana republics have resorted to these systems to plunder the wealth. And to punish the people. Whether they meant to or not, they did punish them. And they did deprive them of various liberties. And in some countries, they butchered millions of people.
Meanwhile, Pope Francis has a lot of reasons to praise various aspects of capitalism. No system has raised the standard of living of people more than capitalism. Witness India, China, South Korea, and Taiwan. Compare life in those countries with life in Vietnam, North Korea, China, and Laos. Compare dismal life in socialist Venezuela with bountiful life in capitalist Chile.
It would be nice if the pontiff recognized some of the good of capitalism. Nice if he noticed that immigrants desperately seek the system he calls evil. Do they know something he doesn’t know?
The pope berated Donald Trump for wanting to build a wall. But notice that the pope does not open the gates of the Vatican to illegal immigrants. He does not berate Cuba for its virtual walls. Cuba is not taking in a few hundred thousand illegals — not that anyone would want to move there. And Cuba has walled in its people for 50 years.
Meanwhile, the Roman Catholic Church is one of the world’s biggest players in the capitalist system.
If you were a peasant, all these contradictions might confuse you.
From Tom...as in Morgan.
Tom Morgan writes about political, financial and other subjects from his home near Oneonta. Several upstate radio stations carry his daily commentary, Tom Morgan’s Money Talk. Contact him at tomasinmorgan@yahoo.com